"Cauldron's records are consistent with what you've said, but you are random people who walked out of a portal in the middle of a rainforest to talk to me and know stuff that I certainly didn't tell you, so do you have any further reason for me to think that Kithabel wasn't a parahuman either or that she needs rescuing or that the entities are bad news in spite of how repulsive their principal opponent appears to have been? I assume if I go talk to ex-Cauldron people they'll be wiped of relevant memories. Which it looks like they had the technology for in-house, if not that precisely."